Gad Gad

What is genius?

Seth takes the pen this week. What is genius? Patterns hiding in plain sight, Socrates’ daimōn, stars too faint to see, genius as a verb, and Thom’s very long list. Plus: fish probably think we’re dumb.

Read More
Gad Gad

What Makes a Good Answer?

Is there such a thing as a perfect answer? Seth keeps asking. This week we wondered whether a good answer finishes a conversation or opens one, whether answers need words at all, and how you know the fish are happy. You can tell by looking.

Read More

Why Do We Hold On to Zombie Ideas?

We talked about why we hold onto disproven ideas. Jim said capitalism is the zombie idea we can't let go of. Jane said zombie ideas come from hope and wait underground to be useful again. Maybe we don't want to feel stupid. We talked about a fake disease called bixonomania, General McChrystal throwing away his portrait of Robert E Lee painting, and being surrounded by a world we can't comprehend so we use heuristics to survive. Also: cognito hazards and Seth wondering what it means to be wise in a post-truth, post-trust society.

Read More
Gad Gad

How Accurate can Language Be?

Seventeen of us showed up on a Wednesday night to ask how accurate language can be, and ended up somewhere between the Tower of Babel, a factory floor where nobody speaks the same language but everybody speaks Factory, and an island in Vanuatu where the grammar is as specific as referring to a particular rock. We talked about Latin, crows, Wittgenstein, a guy who helped invent Java, a Finnish friend who has thoughts she can think but cannot say in English, and why maintaining a language might just be another word for maintaining power. Also: pre-brew. You had to be there. Read the full reflection here.

Read More

Is There a Hierarchy to Morality?

Can you be moral toward your neighbor if you don't love yourself? Should everyone have water, or is that unfair? Tonia wants us to get better at identifying where we depart. A Korean student knows that you are your relationships, without them you cease to exist. We're killers who sometimes bless our kills. Maybe finding common ground is just imperial posturing. Maybe it's the most interesting work in philosophy.

Read More

What Exactly is Death?

What exactly is death? The question seems obvious but gets slippery fast. We explored death as the cessation of change, the end of Pete-ing and Seth-ing, a cultural decision about which indicators matter. We talked about consciousness decomposing and why we keep picking disruptive versions of death in our culture. Jan's mother-in-law apologized in a warehouse dream. Pete wondered if you can die if you're not self-aware. Max held onto his grandpa calling him a good kid. And Luka wants to start a cemetery with fruit trees instead of gravestones.

Read More
Gad Gad

The Gap You Can’t See (and the life you build anyway).

Last night we asked: what is self-deception and how is it even possible? The question begins with a paradox—how can you deceive your own mind? Tim opened with 13,000 days sober and the gift of confronting every layer of self-deception. Jim talked about imposter syndrome and suddenly deception wasn't about lying—it was about the gap we can't see yet. Jane said self-deception is how we make a life, told us about a 50-year marriage built on a story she chose to tell herself. My pen ran out of ink while Bill was asking whether truth can emerge from a lie. Brother Fred watered a dead plant for months because his novice master told him to. Nothing happened to the stick. But something happened to Brother Fred. We never agreed whether self-deception is bad or adaptive, local or global, a gap or a creative force. Maybe it's just the way we course-correct when we can't see the whole picture. The lie we tell ourselves so we can keep moving. The story we build so we can make a life.

Read More

Discrete as I wanna be.

Thom wanted to know: is there such a thing as freewill? Jan's nephew thinks God only cares when you're sad, broken, or dead. Bob's riding hard for complexity. Don won't spoil a 100-year-old book. And I confessed I find determinism comforting—because we're still the vessels through which it all flows, still experiencing choice even if it's not "free."

Read More

Sportsball is an Ethical Circus

Had sick kid, aging is stupid, and I missed Scoundrels. This week you get the raw recording instead of my usual reflection. The whole mess of wrestling with sports and if they have to be ethical - like at their heart are they possible without ethics? Is it cheating if everyone's doing it? What's the difference between fair and ethical? Listen and tell me what you think of this experiment.

Read More
Gad Gad

How Many Scoundrels does it take to Count the Greek Muses?

"What is a muse?" Don asked. He's dealing with creative block and wondering: Can you summon a muse? Imagine one into being? Or does it have to be real?

Fifteen of us wrestled with it. We talked about Greek muses, courtly love, stalking behavior, feminist critique, Hannah the bird sculptor, and whether AI could be a muse.

Read More